The CMA Breakdown: How I Find Your Home’s True Value

What’s a CMA—And Why Should You Care?

If you’ve ever wondered how agents decide on a listing price, here’s the secret—it’s not magic, it’s math… and a little bit of market intuition.

A Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) is the tool I use to determine what your home could realistically sell for in today’s market. It’s not the same as a tax assessment, and it’s definitely not the same as a quick Zillow Zestimate.

The Ingredients of a CMA

A good CMA isn’t just pulling a list of recent sales. Here’s what goes into mine:

• Comparable Sales: Homes of similar size, style, age, and location that have sold recently.

• Active Listings: The competition you’re up against right now.

• Pending Sales: Homes that are under contract, giving us a hint of buyer demand.

• Expired Listings: Properties that didn’t sell—these are cautionary tales about overpricing.

• Adjustments for Features: Pools, renovated kitchens, extra garage bays—these matter.

The “Art” Behind the Numbers

Two houses might be the same square footage, but if one backs up to a busy road and the other has a lake view, their value is very different.

That’s why I also factor in:

• Curb appeal

• Interior condition

• Floor plan flow

• Neighborhood reputation

• School zoning (huge in Germantown & Collierville)

Why It Matters to Sellers

Pricing your home too high can scare off buyers and lead to painful price drops. Pricing too low might leave money on the table. A well-done CMA positions your home to generate strong interest and competitive offers.

A Real Example

I recently priced a home in Collierville where the seller’s neighbor told them, “List it $50,000 higher—people will pay it.” The CMA told a different story. We priced at the market sweet spot, had 18 showings in the first week, and sold above asking because we created demand.

Bottom Line: A CMA is your best friend for smart pricing. It’s the difference between guessing and selling with confidence.